Online Now 1529

The Lions' Pride

Black shoes, basic blues. No names, all game

On this Board 932
Record: 4947 (7/23/2012)

Online now 1281
Record: 7381 (3/13/2012)

Boards ▾

The Lions' Pride

Black shoes, basic blues. No names, all game

Ticket Exchange

Buy, sell and swap tickets

Reply

Need advice - keep BWI?

  • I'm relatively new and also subscribe to BWI. I love 247. Tell me it's ok to only subscribe here.

    tep

  • tep said...

    I'm relatively new and also subscribe to BWI. I love 247. Tell me it's ok to only subscribe here.

    For only $5 a month, you can pay me to tell you everyone on the team looks great, we have 36 silent verbals and I will even make scathing posts about everyone who disagrees with me. Half the price, 100% of the content. Paypal accepted.

    signature image

    #DicedPineapples

    shavisimo2

  • tep said...

    I'm relatively new and also subscribe to BWI. I love 247. Tell me it's ok to only subscribe here.

    I've never subscribed to either of the other sites, so maybe my advice isn't helpful. But the info on here is plenty, especially now with Jeff as an added staff member. Sean does a great job and there's only been once or twice when people have mentioned TOS in terms of info.

    signature image

    psubills62

  • tep said...

    I'm relatively new and also subscribe to BWI. I love 247. Tell me it's ok to only subscribe here.

    You will do more than ok. Ditch the zero and get with the hero.

    szone

    POV

  • tep said...

    I'm relatively new and also subscribe to BWI. I love 247. Tell me it's ok to only subscribe here.

    It's ok to only subscribe here. biggrin

    signature image signature image signature image

    pwpitch

  • tep said...

    I'm relatively new and also subscribe to BWI. I love 247. Tell me it's ok to only subscribe here.

    I was a member of all 3 recruiting sites. I have since cancelled BWI and have kept Scout, 247.

    Why no more BWI? I cannot stand the forums over their (even the paid one). The Wig is overly optimistic with everything and is ridiculous in what he says a lot of times. They do get some good pieces on actual football, but the recruiting info is not that great, though Ryan and Nate do a decent job.

    Why 247? I was originally a member of only BWI and Scout, but tried out the 247 trial around the coaching search, thinking I'd just cancel after the trial. Well, that didnt happen and 247 is now where I spend 95% of my time on PSU football/recruiting, with 5-10% being Scout for some of their PSU football coverage. The forum/community here is growing with solid contributors, the technology here at the 247 site is not ancient like the other 2 and is constantly taking feedback from its users and improving the user experience (both the forums and the web site) cheers to the tech guys at 247. The trolls on this site are almost non-existant and we actually get some good convos going with people from other schools. And most importantly, Fitz is the best in the business at what he does for PSU football recruiting news. Now, with the addition of Jeff Rice to cover PSU football news, this place has firmly planted itself as #1 for PSU football IMO.

    Why Scout? The Marks do a great job over at Scout and the community is alright. The bad things about that community on the TAP Board (I dont venture to Audibles much) is that some posters just jump down other people's throats for posting their opinion. It is a real turnoff. Whereas here, everyone has their own opinion and for the most part everyone is respectful of that opinion. The barometers from PBMark are also great. The recruiting info is lagging behind Fitz.

    This is all IMHO.

    You find out life's this game of inches, so is football. Because in either game, life or football-the margin for error is so small. -Pacino

    tmaluchnik

  • I have FOS and 247. Both of these sites are worthwhile IMO for different reasons. I would never subscribe to bwi

    signature image

    fabfour12324

  • I dropped BWI right after LOI, picked up 247 and have not looked back. Best move I have made. Thinking I am going to drop scout as well.

    tmatt32

  • Dropped BWI a couple years ago, have had scout since. Am probably dropping scout and keeping my VIP at 247. Better and quicker on recruiting info.

    LinebackerU1

  • I have all three right but that is about to change.

    Ryan and Nate work hard at BWI but I find the board tought to read most of the time due to some of the members and I just got tired of the arguing.

    FOS Scout is ok for a lot of general knowledge but the recruiting info is a little slow.

    I like what is going on here because Fitz and the recruiting info is top notch and with the addition of Jeff Rice we are already seeing more team info come our way. In my opinion it's only going to get better here and my days of having all three are nearing an end. I think you'll also find that there are a number of posters here who have a lot of football and recuiting knowledge and don't hesitate to help. i'm really getting up to speed on a topic that I lost touch with 20 years ago.

    Hope that helps.

    robmaio

  • FOS is worth it, but BWI is not. FOS gets some unique info in both recruiting and on the team, but Grosz and BWI don't provide much. I can't imagine the board has improved over there either.

    new-era said... Psu doesnt have enough to beat the conferences better teams and wiscy is one of them.

    leftcoastlion

  • tep said...

    I'm relatively new and also subscribe to BWI. I love 247. Tell me it's ok to only subscribe here.

    with sean and andrew it was worth the price, they just added on Jeff Rice, who since getting here has been overloading people with great articles...without Jeff it was a no brainer....now with Jeff hands down the best penn state coverage around

    i joined 247 based on the 30 day free trial...after that I was hooked...highly recommend doing the trail to help your decision

    This post was edited by Roaringlion on 4/7/2012 at 2:45 PM

    signature image signature image signature image

    Roaringlion

  • I have Scout and 247.... IMO both have strengths and between the two I get everything i want. BWI doesn't bring anything to the table

    JDpsu

  • @tmaluchnik said...
    The bad things about that community on the TAP Board (I dont venture to Audibles much) is that some posters just jump down other people's throats for posting their opinion. It is a real turnoff. Whereas here, everyone has their own opinion and for the most part everyone is respectful of that opinion.

    This board is young and growing. Give it time. There are established relationships over on FOS that have existed for years, and it creates some animosity. As you expand the pool, you'll also get more trolls who can ruin it for everyone. I'll never forget LK.. he ruined every thread for years.

    new-era said... Psu doesnt have enough to beat the conferences better teams and wiscy is one of them.

    leftcoastlion

  • This post is for members of Lions247 only. Join now! Subscribe Now

    restoreThe ROAR

  • fightonstate.com, victorybellrings.com, bwi.rivals.com, nittanylionsden.com, blackshoediaries.com,

    these are some penn state sites i have found on my own FOS stands for fightonstate i believe

    This post was edited by Roaringlion on 4/7/2012 at 9:15 PM

    signature image signature image signature image

    Roaringlion

  • shavisimo2 said...

    For only $5 a month, you can pay me to tell you everyone on the team looks great, we have 36 silent verbals and I will even make scathing posts about everyone who disagrees with me. Half the price, 100% of the content. Paypal accepted.

    I'll call you names if you really want that BWI-like, warm, fuzzy feeling. and I'll take the other $5.

    Seriously, as an ex-BWI-er, you will not regret a second away from there, just my humble opinion though.

    signature image signature image signature image

    That is my name on their tops and no one can tell me any different!!!!

    Jmaus24

  • This post is for members of Lions247 only. Join now! Subscribe Now

    restoreThe ROAR

  • tep said...

    I'm relatively new and also subscribe to BWI. I love 247. Tell me it's ok to only subscribe here.

    Over ten years with BWI.

    Left them and haven't regretted it for a moment.

    mad4psu

  • I subscribe to both FOS and 247. I've tried BWI in the past and found it to be completely worthless. Both sites to which I subscribe have their strengths and weaknesses. Fitz and 247 have taken the mantel as top dog when it comes to recruiting information. Its slower on FOS since Cory James scaled back his contribution to the site. While the forum here is growing I still prefer the TAP Board for most of my posting. While the addition of Jeff Rice will be a huge boost for content on 247, no one is better than Mark Brennan on FOS for insight and info into the current team. I suggest belonging to both, and never under any circumstance give any money to the Pilgrim.

    Ldandy

  • It's really not that hard a decision. If you can afford both and like BWI, then stick with them. You are getting the input here from everybody that dislikes BWI (and Phil specifically), however there are a lot of people who do like it there. Ryan is doing a nice job with recruiting (although not as nice as Sean, IMO) and Nate does do a pretty good job as well. Yes Phil is over the top, but sometimes I need some unbridled optimismbiggrin.

    I was a member to all three, and decided that was utterly ridiculous so I dropped FOS. I just felt their recruiting coverage left the most to be desired out of the three. Their site specific recruiting guy seems to disappeer for long stretches of time.

    Now I'm leaning towards dropping BWI, not because I don't like them but because I like it here better and can find a better place to spend that money.

    ftlawdog

  • I've been on BWI for almost 12 years and on FOS for about 9 and I must say that 247 has become sort of my go to ( I'm a newbie here). Great job 247...

    PSUVA92

  • Obviously it is up to your budget and interests, but i dropped BWI and havent looked back. I find this site to have the most current and complete information available.

    Nit_wit

  • I would be long gone from bwi but I'm a film junkie and they(rivals) have a great amount of film on kids. Will drop them prob in the fall again though.

    This post was edited by psu2013 on 4/7/2012 at 4:27 PM

    signature image

    I guess I should warn you, if I turn out to be particularly clear, you've probably misunderstood what I've said.

    psu2013

  • psu2013 said...

    I would be long gone from bwi but I'm a film junkie and they(rivals) have a great amount of film on kids. Will drop them prob in the fall again though.

    you can always save the money and use youtube.com for film on kids...not sure if they have special videos or not

    signature image signature image signature image

    Roaringlion