Online Now 1405

The Lions' Pride

Black shoes, basic blues. No names, all game

On this Board 2407
Record: 4947 (7/23/2012)

Online now 3242
Record: 7381 (3/13/2012)

Boards ▾

The Lions' Pride

Black shoes, basic blues. No names, all game

Ticket Exchange

Buy, sell and swap tickets

Reply

Get Ready - WSJ Hit Piece on JoePa regarding Discipline

  • It's a fairly ridiculous article, with a whole bunch of crap taken out of context. Especially irking is passing along allegations of what happened in that apartment, as if it were actual fact - when there was ZERO physical evidence to support that story. This guy claims that a bunch of players beat him senseless with a stool, and then continued to beat him...yet there wasn't a single drop of blood, and the only one person went to the hospital, and that person was released with a bump on the head. Not to mention the police, after FULLY investigating the issue, dropped almost all the charges.

    Regarding Dan Connor...really? She tried to suspend him for multiple games for PRANK CALLS? To an ex-coach? I can see why Paterno demanded she be fired in that case.

    There have to be a BUNCH of cases they could have found where Joe protected his case, and think they have a great example of that with EZ Smith. Even the email they use...the actual parts they paste into the article is out of context with the actual email. It makes him seem like he's upset with NCAA academic standards, and then you read the actual email he's upset with the beauracracy and continued random rule making and money grabbing by the NCAA/BCS.

    Oh and then calling him out for playing Anwar Phillips...when he was absolved of all charges?

    Ridiculous article.

    Finally - this gem

    The incident prompted Mr. Spanier to visit Dr. Triponey at her home. Dr. Triponey confirms he told her that Mr. Paterno had given him an ultimatum: Fire her, or Mr. Paterno would stop fund-raising for the school. She says Mr. Spanier told her that if forced to choose, he would choose her over the coach—but that he did not want to have to make that choice.

    Joe Paterno Fought Penn State Official Over Punishment of Football Players - WSJ.com

    Legendary Penn State football coach Joe Paterno clashed repeatedly with the university's former chief disciplinarian over how harshly to punish players who got into trouble, internal emails suggest, shedding new light on the school's effort to balance its reputation as a magnet for scholar-athletes with the demands of running a nationally dominant football program.

    online.wsj.com

    Black Shoes. Basic Blues. No Name. All Game.

    appoo

  • Just saw this scroll on espn. Great stuff. Can only imagine how she would get along with another head coach.

    Gunslinger317

  • I can't speak to the accuracy of any of the stories in the article, and I was unaware of any published code of ethics, but assuming they exist, athletes should not be exempt from them. They should not be treated any differently than the rest of the student body. Based on her emails it seems like Joe thought differently, which would contradict the major tenet of his Grand Experiment.

    signature image

    “We need to keep this (expletive) together,” Mauti and Zordich to Hill

    psujmc1992

  • psujmc1992 said...

    I can't speak to the accuracy of any of the stories in the article, and I was unaware of any published code of ethics, but assuming they exist, athletes should not be exempt from them. They should not be treated any differently than the rest of the student body. Based on her emails it seems like Joe thought differently, which would contradict the major tenet of his Grand Experiment.

    Actually, that's not what Joe said at all. Though I don't agree with his stance either. Check out the actual email in the picture below - Joe wanted to keep the rule of when kids gets in trouble off campus, it doesn't count towards the code of conduct. That would be a standard for ALL students, and he also notes that only one other Big 10 school adopted that. That's not really something I agree with, because as long as you're in semester, you're a student. When you're of out of semester, from PSU's POV they shouldn't care. But I don't think he's trying to seperate football players in this case - at least the email does not indicate that. He's referring to the general rule. But again, I disagree with Coach Paterno in this one. But it's not like he was off the wall here either, apparently only PSU and one other Big 10 school adopted this measure.

    What I will defend him in is that coaches of athletic teams should be responsible of how plays on his or her team. Not administrators.

    I don't think this is an issue of preferential treatment at all. This is just a battle of who gets to do the discipline.

    attachment

    Black Shoes. Basic Blues. No Name. All Game.

    appoo

  • Seems like Joe was pissed at the world. I have never heard of this way of handling discipline. The only thing we will hear about this iis she questioned his ethics and morals.

    Coaches should set discipline in my opinion. Also it is a very interesting question whether the university should punish students for things done off campus. Also what is the typical punishment for a kid that makes prank phone calls, shoots arrows through a wall, is falsely accused of something or even gets in a fight. If kids that are members on intramural sports or clubs did those things are they told they can't partcioate in any faction for a length of time. I've heard of kids being on probation and so forth but not really forbidden to take part in activities for events not relating to said activities. If this is the case she has a point if it isn't then wasn't she trying to punish football players in a way that wasn't/isn't consistent with the rest of the students .

    This post was edited by Gunslinger317 on 11/22/2011 at 1:59 AM

    Gunslinger317

  • appoo said...

    It's a fairly ridiculous article, with a whole bunch of crap taken out of context. Especially irking is passing along allegations of what happened in that apartment, as if it were actual fact - when there was ZERO physical evidence to support that story. This guy claims that a bunch of players beat him senseless with a stool, and then continued to beat him...yet there wasn't a single drop of blood, and the only one person went to the hospital, and that person was released with a bump on the head. Not to mention the police, after FULLY investigating the issue, dropped almost all the charges.

    Regarding Dan Connor...really? She tried to suspend him for multiple games for PRANK CALLS? To an ex-coach? I can see why Paterno demanded she be fired in that case.

    There have to be a BUNCH of cases they could have found where Joe protected his case, and think they have a great example of that with EZ Smith. Even the email they use...the actual parts they paste into the article is out of context with the actual email. It makes him seem like he's upset with NCAA academic standards, and then you read the actual email he's upset with the beauracracy and continued random rule making and money grabbing by the NCAA/BCS.

    Oh and then calling him out for playing Anwar Phillips...when he was absolved of all charges?

    Ridiculous article.

    Finally - this gem

    The incident prompted Mr. Spanier to visit Dr. Triponey at her home. Dr. Triponey confirms he told her that Mr. Paterno had given him an ultimatum: Fire her, or Mr. Paterno would stop fund-raising for the school. She says Mr. Spanier told her that if forced to choose, he would choose her over the coach—but that he did not want to have to make that choice.

    If she quit because of disagreements over how football players should be disciplined, and felt Paterno was catering to them, then that's a problem. I don't like the findings in the article either, and maybe some of it is out of context, but her basis for resignation is disturbing. Spanier told her to reconsider her position because Paterno threatened to quit fundraising. This is not good.

    JD29

  • Couple things

    This is any college football program that does this. Joe turned out to not be quite so different. The country we live in wants justice for anything being said not what people actually do.

    Joe really should have quit after 2001. Pride got in the way and will ruin him.

    The lady sounds like a total jerk to deal with.

    This ends the Bradley talk for HC.

    signature image signature image signature image

    PENN STATE FOREVER

    philafan

  • The man makes a kid sit out of the Citrus Bowl for skipping a few classes. He sits a kid for an entire season for not making the grades he set for him, even though that same player is academically eligible by NCAA standards. He had his players live in Nittany Apts. so they could be like regular students, not isolated and elite. Open container citations that aren't even known at other schools result in multi game suspensions here.

    I am so sickened by what this school and the media are doing to this man. They are lunging for anything negative to sully him, and totally disregarding the good that he did for more than half a century. And for this essentially fabricated hatchet job to come out now? The man is dealing with cancer. Disgusting.

    "I believe in what Coach Paterno set forth.”- Garrett Sickels "A bowl game ain't nothing but a vacation."- Gerald Hodges

    fortheglory94

  • This post is for members of Lions247 only. Join now! 30-Day Free Trial

    Black Shoes. Basic Blues. No Name. All Game.

    appoo

  • I will say this. I think we all can agree that football players are given preferential treatment to a point. But they are also creating huge revenue for the school. The Monday after Ki-Jana Carter was drafted the #1 overall pick in the NFL draft, he was in his 8:00 morning marketing class with me. That is what Joe instilled in these guys. I think Joe did what he felt was right for the kids to become more than football players, but to become men. Everything this man did is now coming under fire. It is getting rather sickening.

    ...and if you're not down with that, then I got 2 words for ya.."suck it!!"

    paupacklion

  • Guess it's time for all journalists who want to achieve notoriety to take a squat and dump on all things Penn State. Especially the school icon.

    Nittany Sluggo

  • Call me crazy but IF any of that really is true...is that LOIC?

    signature image

    PSUjosh11

  • I think it's pretty clear that Triponey has an ax to grind and has been saving those e-mails just waiting for a chance to smear PSU -- if I was her boss now I'd get rid of her for pulling a stunt like that because I'd be concerned she would try to smear me next.

    jetli

  • jetli said...

    I think it's pretty clear that Triponey has an ax to grind and has been saving those e-mails just waiting for a chance to smear PSU -- if I was her boss now I'd get rid of her for pulling a stunt like that because I'd be concerned she would try to smear me next.

    It doesn't sound like she sought out the press or gave up the emails. Seems like they found the emails and asked her about them.

    signature image

    “We need to keep this (expletive) together,” Mauti and Zordich to Hill

    psujmc1992

  • " The incident prompted Mr. Spanier to visit Dr. Triponey at her home. Dr. Triponey confirms he told her that Mr. Paterno had given him an ultimatum: Fire her, or Mr. Paterno would stop fund-raising for the school. She says Mr. Spanier told her that if forced to choose, he would choose her over the coach—but that he did not want to have to make that choice. "

    Plus Triponey conveniently leaves out the fact that she publicly demanded Joe be fired over remarks he made when a Florida St football player was falsely accused of rape the week before the 2006 Orange Bowl. Vicky Triponey is a raging uber-feminist on her own power-trip who believes anyone born with a penis is GUILTY and who constantly meddled in Joe's program and insisted she should be determing how Joe should discipline his players with regard to the football field and anyone who believes she'd have held Joe's players to the same standards and subjected them to the same discipline as the general student body is an absolute fool. She had one hell of an axe to grind and the WSJ could not possibly have found a less objective source. I had expected the WSJ to vet their sources a whole lot better than this until I recalled it's now run by Rupert Murdoch and is in no way the same WSJ I grew up with. It's now no differerent and no better than the News of the World.

    Catchy phrase or quote

    mhentz

  • PSUjosh11 said...

    Call me crazy but IF any of that really is true...is that LOIC?

    If anything I would say it is typical of athletic programs across the country. For example look at the fights Spurier and Rich Rodd had when they took over at SC and UM as they relate to accepting NCAA qualified athletes that had been offered scholarships. No coach wants to be told how to discipline their players as far as athletic practice and competitions are concerned. What is the punishment for a non-athlete that gets a MIP or DUI? Why should a person on the punishment board get to say Connor can't play for half a season for a prank call?

    helpdesk

  • The Connor thing is absurd. I'm not saying that this makes it right, but I highly doubt that a player of Connor's caliber would be suspended at a single other major program for something as small as some stupid prank calls. That example is just ludicrous. Not defending Connor's moronic actions, but let's get real here. No school is squeaky to the point where a Connor type player would get anything more than internal discipline.

    Seeing as Anwar was acquitted, that example shouldn't be included either.

    Not going to lie, this woman kind of sounds like a major b***h.

    PSUatw

  • Boy - wow - you knew these articles would start coming out once the power was gone. The article and comments attributed to Spanier seem counter to the argument that he's been out to get Paterno fired.

    gianluca

  • The WSJ interviewing the dude from the apartment and refusing to point out the utter lack of evidence to support those allegations told me all I needed to know about what the WSJ was aiming for here.

    Black Shoes. Basic Blues. No Name. All Game.

    appoo

  • Wait an academic thinks there is preferential treatment given to football players? And this is news?

    Next you will be telling me some professors are mad/jealous that football coaches make a ton more money than they do....

    MTayl72

  • Maybe it's just me, but I don't see the big deal in anything contained in that article. Nothing new really came out of it, as we have all known for years that Joe preferred to keep things "in house" when it comes to players. It is not to say Joe never diciplined them, but he knew that football players getting in trouble unfairly putthose players all over ESPN, when that same trouble by an average student never batted an eyelash. I think Joe always tried to protect his players from public embarassment, but preferred to dicipline in his own way.

    kjc15600

  • MTayl72 said...

    Wait an academic thinks there is preferential treatment given to football players? And this is news?

    Next you will be telling me some professors are mad/jealous that football coaches make a ton more money than they do....

    This this and this.

    Still, as everything comes out, I got a feeling we are going to know what Joe was really like, and hopefully some of you will take down your shrines to him.

    signature image

    I guess I should warn you, if I turn out to be particularly clear, you've probably misunderstood what I've said.

    psu2013

  • psujmc1992 said...

    It doesn't sound like she sought out the press or gave up the emails. Seems like they found the emails and asked her about them.

    How are they going to "find" the e-mails? The only way a reporter is going to get his hands on them is if a PSU employee saves them and turns them over voluntarily, and only someone with an agenda. So who would do that? It's either a current employee or somebody who left on bad terms -- in other words, everything points to her.

    jetli

  • jetli said...

    How are they going to "find" the e-mails? The only way a reporter is going to get his hands on them is if a PSU employee saves them and turns them over voluntarily, and only someone with an agenda. So who would do that? It's either a current employee or somebody who left on bad terms -- in other words, everything points to her.

    I don't think that's right. Didn't ESPN sue OSU for access to emails that OSU was trying to suppress?

    signature image

    “We need to keep this (expletive) together,” Mauti and Zordich to Hill

    psujmc1992

  • psu2013 said...

    This this and this.

    Still, as everything comes out, I got a feeling we are going to know what Joe was really like, and hopefully some of you will take down your shrines to him.

    Uh, nothing in that article on Paterno's part that I disagree with. Shrine still intact? Thanks.

    helpdesk